Black Hills Insurance Agency, Inc. is a family owned independent insurance agency owned and operated by the Maguire family. For over 60 years, Black Hills Insurance has grown with the community to become one of the largest and most service orientated agencies in the region. With offices in Rapid City and Spearfish, we specialize in the sale and service of commercial property and casualty insurance. The company’s commitment to excellence is evident in the partnerships they enjoy with the elite of Black Hills and West River clients.

Black Hills Agency currently holds direct contracts with General Casualty Insurance Companies: The Chubb Group: Travelers Insurance Companies: Chartis: American Trust North America: Auto Owners: MMIC: Midwest Family Mutual Insurance Co.: The Hartford: Continental Western Group: Dakota Truck and First Indemnity: National Farmers Union: Western National Insurance and United Fire Group. In addition, the company works with several MGA companies to access specialty programs and markets.

Although the Agency specializes in service for large complex accounts, Black Hills Agency continues its tradition of service to the small and medium size businesses that populate the Black Hills community. The company’s personal lines department is dedicated to clients that demand and receive the personal attention their accounts require. Regardless of market cycles, the Agency’s growth remains steady. Black Hills Agency’s client base includes clients from the construction industry: hospital/physician industry: automobile/garage industry: tourism and gaming industry, along with public entity business.   Emphasis on client relationships is the key to the Agency’s success and continued financial investment in value added services allows the agency to continually exceed client expectations. The combined years of service with our clients exceeds 235 years. The longest relationship is over 40 years and speaks volumes to the company’s history of customer satisfaction.

With our desire of continued growth in the Northern Hills, Black Hills Insurance is pleased to announce the opening of our Spearfish location. Our new facility will allow us to accommodate and service the needs of our existing Northern Hills clients, as well as increase our presence in the area.

As part of an elite group of independent insurance agencies around the United States, Black Hills Agency was included in the IIAA’s “Best Practices” Study Group. With over 800 agencies nominated, only 180 agencies qualified based on their outstanding customer services, growth, stability and financial management. The “Best Practices” Study publication is used by almost all independent agencies in the United States for comparison of benchmark statistics.

Aside from being very active in their local, state and national trade associations, the Maguires have been very active in the Rapid City Community including the United Way Board, Story Book Island, Black Hills Workshop Foundation, Christmas in April, Black Hills Children’s Home Society, Rapid City Rotary Clubs, and many, many youth sport activities.

Discover what sort of coverage you require: Ask for a non-binding consultation today!

To learn more, follow these links:

Personal insurance

Commercial insurance